Versatile Silicone Oil Emulsions - Syntheses, Properties and Applications
Hemanth Kumar K.1,2, Padma Thiagarajan2, Thiagarajan N.1*
1Material Science Division, National Aerospace Laboratories, CSIR, Bangalore
2School of Bioscience and Technology, VIT University, Vellore
*Corresponding Author E-mail: drthiagarajan@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT:
Silicone oils owe their versatility and biocompatibility to their unique properties due to which they are being widely applied in the cosmetic and pharmaceutical industries today. One of the possible formulations by which these oils can be used is in the form of micro and nanoemulsions. Kinetic stability of these emulsions has been addressed in terms of thermodynamic concepts. Various simple and advanced methods exist for their preparation which are of the oil in water and water in oil types. Double emulsions have demonstrated superiority over the single ones and can be prepared by traditional two step and novel single step processes. Emulsion formulations require the incorporation of suitable emulsifiers into the system and studies on biocompatibility of such emulsifiers have revealed the non ionic ones to be more suitable than ionic types. Pronounced emulsifier activity has also been noticed with multifunctional polymeric silicone based emulsifiers, due to their strong absorption at oil in water interface. Toxicity studies have proved that silicone oil systems exhibit low order toxicity, except in very few cases. Biocompatibility can additionally be improved by the usage of bio based surfactants. Applications of silicone oil emulsions in cosmetics, medicine and pharmaceutics have been discussed here.
KEYWORDS: Silicone oils, Emulsions, Surfactants, HLB, cosmetology, Pharmacology.
INTRODUCTION:
The first isolable organosilicon compound was synthesized in 1888 by Kipping1. However, the era of silicone oil emulsions began in 1980’s when non-aqueous emulsions were synthesized from them2,3 and their use, as potential vehicles for toiletries gained momentum4. The development and availability of multiple silicone and other polymer based emulsifiers facilitated the application of these non-aqueous emulsions as vehicles for cosmetic ingredients and as systems for the delivery for a diverse variety of different products for personal care. Silicone oils, or in other words, siloxanes, comprise of a special class of polymers which may be of different types including those of hybrid inorganic or inorganic ones. Further they may be structurally linear or cyclic polymers with versatile applications in cosmetics5,6, drug delivery systems7, textiles8,9, home care products10,11, printing ink formulations12, semipermeable membranes13, etc. As a consequence of modern requirements in cosmetics and pharmaceutics, new approaches to drug delivery methods with greater bioavailability and distinctive formulations have evolved. Silicone oil nanoemulsions are one such type of formulations which have recently garnered a great deal of attention.
The exceptional properties of silicone oil has triggered its use in drug delivery systems and in a variety of cosmoceutical and pharmaceutical products.
Silicone oil, an important synthetic polymer, has a backbone of Si-O-Si, and a general formula of (R2SiO)n. Its exceptional flexibility is due to the Si-O-Si bonds, which show a torsional force constant of a very low value, thus making silicone oil available in variable viscosities ranging from 0.65 to 1,00,000 cst, with a Tg of 123°C14. Polydimethylsiloxanes (PDMS), one of the most common silicone derivatives exhibits high hydrophobicity due to the presence of gem methyl groups. The relatively high ionic Si-O bond imparts exceptional surface properties to the silicone oil. The surface tension with respect to these silicones shows a direct proportionality to molecular weight, which varies from about 16 mN/m for Me3SiO-(Me2SiO)n - SiMe3,
for n values of zero, to values between 20- 21 mN /m in case of silicones of medium and high molecular weight, with n values greater than ten15. Further, it was found that self emulsifying drug delivery systems enhance the stability of water soluble or lipophobic drugs16.
The present review focuses on the syntheses methods available for silicone oil emulsions along with their properties and applications in biomedical fields as well as in personal care products and pharmacology.
Types of emulsions and emulsification methods
Emulsification is a non-equilibrium process17 and the basic chemistry of emulsions18-23 apply to micro and nanoemulsion too. The main difference between micro and nanoemulsion is not based on composition but rather on thermodynamics24-26. Microemulsion formation is a thermodynamically feasible process whereas the formation of nanoemulsion is not. Comparatively, microemulsions have lower free energies than the phase separated states, which explains the thermodynamic differences between the two. The kinetic stability can be elucidated by energy barriers and mass transport phenomena. Microemulsions cannot be stored for long time as they may degrade due to various environmental factors, but nanoemulsions, with energy barriers of > 20 kT (k is the Boltzmann constant and T is the absolute temperature referring to thermal energy of the system) can be stored for a longer time, indicating that the height of the energy barrier determines the kinetic stability of these emulsions27. Nanoemulsions are prone to destabilization through various mechanisms which involve Ostwald’s ripening, flocculation, gravitational separation, etc. Hence their kinetic stabilities may be improved by incorporating micro structure emulsifiers, weight modifiers and ripening retarders into them28. The preparative methods, properties and applications of nanoemulsions in general have been reviewed 29-32.
Silicone oil emulsions have largely been prepared using conventional methods such as homogenization33, ultrasonication34 and mechanical stirring35. The process of emulsification requires a high shear force to rupture the droplets followed by stabilization of the surfactant. Phase Inversion temperature (PIT) method36 is a low flow emulsification method, where there is a change in interfacial properties of emulsion at the PIT. PIT generally involves the use of non-ionic surfactants. Either oil in water emulsions (O/W i.e., direct) or water in oil (W/O i.e., inverse) emulsions can be prepared by diverse emulsifications procedures. A rather simple and direct method to synthesise droplets of nano range involves high flow emulsification. In this procedure, a shear force is applied externally and this overcomes the viscous/ interfacial stress, which is present internally. This leads to the breaking of the larger droplets in the solution into smaller sized ones. Microfluidic homogenization involving high pressure37-39 and ultrasonic emulsification40-42 are capable of producing emulsions down to diameters below 100nm43-45.
Ultracentrifugal fractionation has been used for emulsion synthesis as this method improves the size distribution uniformity of Polydimethyl siloxanes - water system 17. It is an easy procedure which employs the variations seen in the rates of creaming between the droplets which are of different sizes, when they react to a buoyant force which arises because of the differences in density between oil and water. Nanoemulsion composite micro gels, a cross linkable nanoemulsion, can be synthesized by flow lithography with controlled droplet size, loading and stability46. Photo polymerization of the oil in pregel nanoemulsion results in the formation of a chemically cross linked hydrogel in the continuous phase. A detailed account on flow lithography and droplet based methods is available in the literature47.
Emulsions can be synthesised by dispersing droplets of one liquid dispersion in a second liquid medium. These are labelled as ternary / double emulsions or simply “emulsions of emulsions”. They form very complex dispersion systems and can of two types, viz., water-in-oil-in-water (W/O/W) or oil-in-water-in-oil (O/W/O). Traditionally, a two-step fabrication method has been used to prepare double emulsions of w/o/w type48. Initially, a surfactant with a low Hydrophilic Lipophilic Balance (HLB) is employed under conditions of high flow. This surfactant is first dissolved in the oil employed in emulsion preparation and it stabilises the latter as per the requirements of Bancroft’s rule49 leading to the formation of inverse emulsion. This is followed by the addition of W/O emulsion, to the water which already has the surfactant with high HLB incorporated into it. The emulsification is then carried out with a low flow rate, which avoids the process of destruction and coalescence of internal droplets, leading to the formation water in oil emulsion. Polymeric surfactants are mainly used for the stabilization of emulsions prepared by such methods as these tend to adsorb with a higher strength at the interface as compared to the emulsions which are of monomeric types. Stabilisation of the droplets can be achieved by using polymers which do so by mechanisms which involve both steric and depletion stabilisation50. Polysiloxanes, which are structurally grafted with moieties of non-ionic poly (ethylene oxide) are very versatile due to their strong absorption at W/O interface, thus indicating that silicone based polymers are excellent with respect to their higher levels of emulsifying power51,52. Further, silicone-derived polymers enhances the elasticity of the interfacial film due to their strong absorption to the O/W interface which explains the stability of these emulsions.
Double emulsions, which are monodisperse, have also been synthesised by the process of microfluidic flow focusing53 and those involving T-junctions54. An O/W/O emulsion can be produced in a single step emulsification process involving the procedure of compound drop (surfactant solution in oil) which later turns to a double emulsion 55. The compound drop is made with the help of a couple of syringes filled with surfactant solution and oil, with their ends held by a thin copper wire. The solution of the surfactant and the drops of oil are dropped from the syringes and they slide onto the wire and they terminate at the lowest point and finally merge to form the corresponding compound drop and bouncing on vibrated liquid surface. SDS solution favours the deformation of the oil/water interface at concentrations ten times to that of the Critical Micellar Concentration.
The preparation of monodisperse double-emulsion for viscous liquids had remained a challenge for several years. A method which involves biphasic flow of two liquids in a microcapillary device has now solved the problem56. Double emulsion drops, with a core- shell geometry having an ultra-thin wall as a middle layer, is found to be suitable for both kinds of double emulsions viz, O/W/O or W/O/W. In spite of the small thickness of middle layer, they show high stability and biodegradable microcapsules of Polylactic acid, created by using this method, are potentially useful in drug delivery, cosmetics and also for encapsulation procedures.
Double emulsions due to their internal compartmentalization, offer several advantages over traditional O/W emulsions, as they can carry both polar or non-polar molecules, thus enhancing their applications in cosmetics and pharmaceutical products. Water in oil in water double emulsions have been synthesised in a nanoscale, by employing the process of high flow emulsification along with a diblock co polypeptide (DBC) amphiphile which is molecularly designed57. Here, the control of H-bond presentation, in polypeptide segments, acts as a stabilizing factor. Multi compartment Poly (dimethylsiloxane) particles have been produced using (W/O/W) systems as templates and these can be used in controlled drug delivery and enzyme immobilization58. These emulsions are prone to destabilization and are hence stabilized by a kinetic process which involves the addition of hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfactants. The mechanism of stabilisation possibly involves the surfactants encompassing the inner water molecules and oil globules, respectively59. Diffusive transport studies of W/O/W emulsions have shown the requirement of osmotic regulators to maintain the concentration gradient between the inner and outer compartments of water phase 60.
Role of surfactants
Stability of the silicone oil emulsions can be attained by employing surfactants which aid in decreasing the interfacial tension observed between the fluid and water junctions. The mechanism involves dispersion of droplets by preventing their coagulation and flocculation. Thorough studies on silicone oil emulsions have revealed non ionic surfactants to be more effective for emulsification than ionic ones for different applications. However in some cases, anionic surfactants have also been employed61. Development of new generation emulsions has extended the use of organic surfactants to silicone based emulsifiers, which invariably possess one or more hydrophilic groups (mostly poly oxyethylene). Moreover, multifunctional polymeric silicone emulsifiers absorb more strongly at the interface than the low molecular weight surfactants, due to their attachment at interface via several segments, thus leading to greater absorption energy. Lowering of the interfacial tension in case of aqueous systems may be a positive character for non-ionic surfactants, but their tolerance towards pH variations is very low and they hydrolyze to form long chain alcohols. The latter have been proved to be skin irritants, and hence this factor limits the use of non ionic surfactants for a wide range of pH.
Factors affecting Emulsification:
Emulsion stability can be influenced by various factors such as silicone oil viscosity, emulsification time, emulsifier concentration, etc 62. A new method based on automated stability dispersion analyser (DiStA 24), for studying the emulsion stability has been proposed 63. As the viscosity of silicone oil increases, the droplet size also increases leading to destabilization of emulsions 64-67. Investigations have shown that emulsions synthesised using oils of low viscosity have lower viscosities than prepared using high viscous oils62. Generally with increase in surfactant concentration, the droplet size decreases. Simultaneously, uniformity of emulsions can also be improved, leading to enhancement of emulsion stability68. After reaching a certain point, further increase in surfactant concentration does not reduce the droplet size, leading to broad size distribution69. During ultrasonication, an increased mixing time leads to decreased droplet size resulting in higher volume fractions and increased viscosity. This leads to enhanced emulsion stability. In contrast, emulsions synthesised using Span 60 emulsifiers, by mechanical stirring method with prolonged emulsification time, were of poor stability, due to high volume fraction, which often ultimately lead to droplets coagulation70,71. Shear force is another critical parameter, affecting the emulsion stability, which can be varied with the time of mixing. With Span 60 emulsions, as the shear force increases, the size distribution becomes narrow, all within a fixed time duration. However, in case of CO - 530 emulsifier, the droplet diameter was found to be in agreement with Span 60 until it reached a critical point of shear force, after which the size of the droplets varied proportionally with time, leading to poor emulsion stability 72. High shear force and increased time for mixing may possibly result in higher rate of collisions among the droplets, which would culminate in broader size distribution of particles and deteriorated emulsion stability. This highlights the importance of using a shear force which is optimum and time which is conducive to enhance the stability of these emulsions.
Applications of Silicone oil based emulsions:
Silicone oil nanoemulsions are widely utilised in various fields which include cosmetology, ophthalmology and dermatology. They also find use in the treatment of gastrointestinal infections and discomfort and protein encapsulation (enzyme immobilization) procedures. Their applications as potential drug delivery systems at nano level are also important73. Broadly these applications can be classified into two categories viz., personal care products and pharmacological / pharmaceutical preparations.
Cosmetic and Personal Care Products
With improvement in the standard of living, the demand for cosmetics and items of personal care has moved from away from traditional merchandise to products which add value to good grooming and social acceptance rather than wellness and health. This paradigm shift has galvanised the cosmetic scientists to research and develop formulations which are superior and very distinctive for consumer requirements. In the process, considerably large amounts of surfactants, stabilizers and electrolytic suspensions are being used in these formulations which may cause skin irritation, dry skin, inflammation and allergic reactions74-79. In this scenario, silicone oil emulsions have come out as prospective systems to solve the limitations seen traditionally in age old formulations80-82. Their uniform and size controllable properties, along with improved appearance, stability and good application performance have enhanced their usage. Coalescence and ostwald ripening are also inhibited in these systems as their size distribution is very narrow83,84.
Silicone oil is an important constituent of hair conditioners, and serves the purpose of preservation of moisture and also lubricates the hair85-87. This oil has different characteristics compared to other counter organic oils. For example, thermodynamic stability of Si-O-Si bond, greater structural flexibility, large permeability, high lubricant property, resistance towards chemicals and UV light have made them unique as versatile conditioning agents in formulations relating to hair and skin88,89. However, silicone oil may have a difficulty in getting absorbed directly onto the hair surface as it is very hydrophobic. To improve silicone deposition on hair, different polymers are being added into shampoos and conditioners90. Employing nanoemulsions containing silicone oil, which are very stable, provides a potential solution to this problem. Addition of cationic conditioning polymer surfactants have resulted in deposition of silicone oil to hair and has solved the problem of shampoos functioning as both cleansing and conditioning agents 91. Emulsions of amino functional silicones and high molecular weight silicones are also widely used in hair care compositions to provide various aesthetic benefits 92. Current trends of synthesis and stabilization of these emulsions for hair care products has been reviewed 62.
Silicone emulsions for personal care is commercialised as antiperspirant formulations/ lotions/creams for skin care and UV protection 93,94. They are largely W/O emulsions which incorporate all the best properties with respect to silicones and include very good spreading behaviour and film forming, glossiness and a dry non sticky feel52. Antiperspirants made from concentrated aqueous aluminium chlorohydrate, emulsified in cyclic dimethylsiloxanes is an important formulation which can be applied with ease. Siloxanes aid thorough application by lowering the stickiness of chlorohydrate and also evaporates without a feeling of a“chill effect”.
Biomedical and pharmaceutical applications
Silicone compounds, by themselves, can be used for various pharmacological applications and one such compound is simethicone, which is commonly employed for the treatment of gastrointestinal discomfort. Simethicone, an orally administered anti-foaming agent, comprises of a suspended mixture of poly dimethylsiloxane and hydrated silica gel. It is generally administered to reduce bloating in the stomach or intestines. Simethicone does not reduce or prevent gas formation in the digestive tract. However, it enhances the rate at which the gas leaves the body 95. Silicone oil nanoemulsions have garnered attention as they retain the functionality of protein during encapsulation procedures, which in turn, bestows them with improved performance and stability.
Skin Care
Emulsions can be used for transdermal delivery of drugs and by adopting this method, the gastrointestinal tract absorption can be bypassed. This method thus improves the bioavailabilty of drug molecules 96.Various cosmetic agents such as after shave lotions 97, sun screen lotions98-100 etc. have been synthesized as emulsions of water in silicone oil. A method for barrier formulation, used in creams and lotions, comprising of silicone based emulsion has been reported 101. Emulsions prepared from silicone oils, in hydrogenated lecithin, were shown to be dermatologically active and the effect of lecithin on dermal safety of this emulsion has been thoroughly investigated, by the measurement of interfacial tension, using Ring method 102. Interfacial tension measurements for two systems viz., surfactant solution containing lecithin with paraffin oil and with silicone oil respectively, have revealed that with the raise in surfactant concentration, both systems show enhanced interfacial tension values. Further dynamic interfacial tension studies, of systems with Lecinol S 10 and Tween 60, at the same flow rate, have shown the formation of Lecinol S 10 and silicone oil nano emulsion system with small sizes of particles and very good stability. The conditions of formation have also been standardised 103. The silicone nano emulsion prepared from hydrogenated lecithin has shown zero value in the Patch Test and hence can be considered dermatologically safe. A health care active formulation of silicone oil emulsion, comprising of silicone gum/resin/PSA and ethylene oxide/propylene oxide copolymer has been patented and this can incorporate a wide range of molecules of therapeutic significance such as vitamins, retinols, anti microbial agents, plant extracts and anti parasitic agents 104.
Silicone emulsions as encapsulating systems:
Generally, isolated proteins are prone to a denaturation process during which they undergo structural changes to lose their functionality. Methods to prevent such denaturation mechanisms have received great deal of attention and this has lead to the recognition of the significance of silicone oil emulsion systems for encapsulating proteins and organic molecules, which find applications in controlled and targeted drug delivery. But, all proteins are not amphiphilic in nature due to which they cannot absorb onto oil-water interfaces. Virus like droplets (VLDs), prepared by using silicone oil nanoemulsion for cowpea chlorotic mottle virus, is composed of an outer protein shell or capsid and inner RNA as genetic material. The capsid, composed of proteins, can be extracted in pure form by altering the pH and ionic strength105 and can then be self assembled around stabilised silicone oil droplets of nanosize, anionically. This leads to the formation of virus like droplets (VLDs)106 which are very much suitable for loading drug molecules.
Many polydimethylsiloxanes which are linear as well as cyclic in nature107, are hydrophobic and hence denature a number of proteins 108,109. However, these interactions with silicones (including with organic lipids e.g., in foods 110,111) are not essentially harmful to the biomolecules. On the other hand, some of these interactions are highly beneficial and important. They serve to fulfill several applications in the cosmetic industry and also industries dealing with the manufacture of personal care products75. Many proteins may not necessarily be influenced by contact with some types of silicone surfactants which have been modified hydrophilically. For example, polyalkylene oxide-modified silicone which has a comb like structure 107(e.g., DC3225C) forms stable products. Lysozyme and R-chymotrypsin, when trapped in water-in silicone oil emulsions, retain their ability to process substrates for a nine day period and the levels are comparable to that of controls. In the presence of triethoxysilyl terminated silicone polymer, TES-PDMS, a modified silicone oil encapsulated albumin, retains the functionality in its water in silicone emulsions. Further it was found that both Human Serum Albumin (HSA) and TES-PDMS are important for formulating stable water-in-silicone oil emulsions112. Fluorescent measurements have shown that no denaturation of HSA is seen in the initially formed, stable emulsion and confocal microscopic studies have revealed the preferential absorption at the oil/water interface.
Prefilled syringes are one of the promising storage and delivery methods which are generally used in parenteral administration of drugs /vaccines. They are very convenient for medicos and patients. However, if the proteins are exposed to silicone oil for protracted time inside such syringes there may be numerous problems. Systems made of silicone oil prepared in buffer emulsions of aqueous nature and model proteins, in formulations incorporating the surfactant, suitable salts like sodium chloride, or sucrose have been described113. The kinetic stability, effects of silicone oil on protein stability and effects of variables controlling protein formulations, on emulsion stability have been thoroughly investigated.
A systematic investigation of BSA encapsulation in polylactic-co-glycolic-acid (PLGA) has been carried out using the formation of a W/O/W emulsion followed by solvent removal. High yields of microsphere fabrication has been achieved by using silicon oil containing methylene chloride as a suspension medium instead of pure silicone oil, with minimal loss of polymer and protein drug (<2%)114. Microencapsulation methods for delivery of protein drugs have been reviewed115. These methods include solvent evaporation / extraction, phase separation (coacervation), spray drying, ionotropic gelation /polyelectrolyte complexation, interfacial polymerization and supercritical fluid precipitation. Each method has been described for its applications, advantages and limitations.
Proteins are currently being available in large quantities and hence finding applications as catalysts (enzymes) and drugs. Simultaneously newer strategies are being developed for their controlled delivery. Immobilization of enzymes such as Chymotrypsin and Lysozyme, by using silicone based surfactants, has been described107 and the retention of functionality conformed by spectrophotometric assays. The study on the adsorption of horseradish peroxidase (HRP) onto silicon wafers has also been reported 116. A detailed mechanism for stabilization of water in silicone oil emulsions by Peptide-Silicone Hybrid Polymers, named as active interfacial modifier (AIM), forms an interesting study where an independent third phase between immiscible two liquid phases has been formed 117. The presence of this third phase was confirmed by fluorescence probe method with Confocal Laser Scanning Microscopy. The synthesis involves reaction between a fluorescence probe (9-Chloromethylanthracene, 9-CMA) with carbonyl groups of silk peptides.
Emulsions formed from cyclic silicone oil and water, used in same proportions, and stabilized with the help of fumed silica nanoparticles can be inverted from oil-in-water (O/W) to water-in-oil (W/O) type. This can be achieved by merely increasing particle concentration 118. Inversion is restricted to systems with particles of intermediate hydrophobicity when dispersed in oil. However, emulsions which are formulated from the same particles, but initially dispersed in water remain O/W at all particle concentrations. Highly hydrophobic particles stabilize only W/O emulsions, and highly hydrophilic ones stabilize only O/W emulsions. These emulsions do not coalescence but creaming and / or sedimentation does occur as a function of time. With the help of rheology, TEM and light scattering experiments, it has been seen that particle dispersions in oil, at high concentrations, consist of connected aggregates in a gel whereas such aggregates remain discrete in aqueous dispersions. Functional silicone and proteins, in combination, lower the interfacial tension of water-in-silicone oil emulsions much more efficiently than the surfactants alone, which elucidates the synergistic interaction between the protein and silicones 119.
Multicompartment poly (dimethylsiloxane) particles were synthesised initially by using templates of water-in-oil-in water (W/O/W) emulsions55. Various silicone W/O/W emulsions have also been successfully synthesised with low viscosity silicone precursors. Fluorescein, a model hydrophilic molecule, has been chosen as encapsulating molecule and the technique of fluorescent optical microscopy has been used for real time monitoring of the formation of loaded multiple emulsions along with their cross-linking processes. Salt incorporation at low concentrations, in the inner aqueous phase, did not influence the emulsion behaviour. However, it was found that high concentrations of salt destabilises the emulsion.
Toxicology and biocompatibility:
The most widely used silicone, polydimethylsiloxanes, a synthetic polymer, is considered safe as no toxicity has been observed after its administration through different exposure routes which are typically used for drug administration. Silicones, are largely of high molecular weight and hence their absorption through the gastrointestinal tract is negligible. Their excretion is carried out without any structural modification. Their dermal absorption is also minimum120. No mutagenic effects have reported through in vitro studies. Silicones, when administered repeatedly through the oral or cutaneous route have not found to exert any effect on different types of species. However inhalation of any types of aerosols, including those of silicones, may cause physical disturbances to the epithelial cell lining of the lungs and associated effects may be observed121. But in the case of Simethicone, mild diarrhea, nausea, regurgitation and vomiting are observed as the common side effects. Low molecular weight siloxanes are used in skin care products and antiperspirants, due to their volatile nature and dry skin feeling. None have these have been identified as toxic except cyclic siloxanes with formula, (SiMe2O)4, which showed a significant lowering of sites of implantation in uterus of female rats when are exposed to it122. However, this effect has not been not observed in case of humans. The next higher homologue of cyclosiloxane i.e., (SiMe2O)5, was shown not to have these effects122.
Usage of biosurfactant, however, reduces the pharmacological side effects such as inflammation, irritation and squalae bioaccumulation, which are generally imposed in the case of synthetic surfactants123. These surfactants basically originate from either carbohydrate or amino acid sources and tend to undergo biodegradation easily. Glycosides, a class of carbohydrates, are found to be actively used in cosmetics124. Microcrystals of cyclodextrin-oil inclusion complexes stabilizes O/W emulsions and resembles pickering emulsions125. Cyclodetxtrin stabilized silicone oil emulsion resembles pickering emulsions as it involves cyclodextrin-oil inclusion complexes, synthesized by threading cylcodextrin from the aqueous phase, onto silicone oil from the emulsion drop surface. Silicones grafted with β-cyclodextrin undergoes spontaneous emulsification and enables the incorporation of greoseofulvin to form an inclusion complex. However, this is a difficult task owing to the low water solubility of greoseofulvin 126.
The innocuous behavior of silicones highlight their versatile usage wherever there is a requirement of extended and long time contact with human body. This is particularly true in case of cosmetics, textile fabrics, food preservative containers and medical appendages and equipments. The low chemical reactivity displayed by silicones, along with low surface area and hydrophobic nature is important for serving these applications and contribute to their excellent biocompatibility 122.
CONCLUSION:
The exceptional properties of silicone oil allow it to be used in the formulation of micro and nanoemulsions which can be applied as excellent systems in fields of cosmetology, dermal care, enzyme immobilization and biomedical research. The interactions of proteins with silicone oil sometimes may cause their denaturation due to the hydrophobic nature of silicones. But in case of hydrophilically modified silicone nanoemulsions, the proteins get stabilized and retain their functionality. Synergistic interactions between protein and silicones have been investigated. The mechanisms of interactions have been studied and conformational studies of protein absorption have also been established by using Confocal Laser Scanning microscopy. Double emulsions with silicones have proved to be useful as encapsulating systems for several active pharmaceutical ingredients and medically important dyes.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:
KHK thanks UGC-CSIR for providing a junior research fellowship. The authors thank National Aerospace Laboratories, Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, Bangalore and VIT University, Vellore for providing the facilities for the preparation of this review.
REFERENCES:
1. Mittal KZ and Pizzi A, Ed. Handbook of Sealant Technology. CRC Press. Taylor and Francis group. Boca Raton, FL. 2009: 13-14.
2. Imhof A and Pine DJ. Stability of non-aqueous emulsions. Journal of Colloid Science and Technology.192; 1997: 368-374.
3. Army-Elizabeth K, et al. Non-aqueous Silicone emulsions. US patent 6060546A. 2000.
4. Paul T and Berkeley Heights NJ. Non-aqueous emulsions: History and current specialized applications. Cosmetics & Toiletries. 128; 2013: 360-364.
5. Newton J, et al. Silicone technologies as delivery systems via Physical associations. Cosmetics & Toiletries 119; 2004: 69-70, 72-74, 76-78.
6. Starch MS. Personal-care emulsions comprising a siloxane-oxyalkylene copolymer. US patent 4311695A. 1982.
7. Maeda H, et al. Novel drug delivery device using silicone: controlled release of insoluble drugs or two kinds of water soluble drugs. Chemical and Pharmaceutical Bulletin. 51; 2003: 15-19.
8. Bajaj P. Finishing of textile materials. Journal of Applied Polymer Science. 83; 2000: 631-659.
9. Purohit P, et al. Studies of properties of modified silicone at the solid-liquid interface: fabric silicone interactions. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science. 298; 2006: 987-990.
10. Somasundaran P, et al. Silicone emulsions. Advances in Colloid and Interface Science. 128-130; 2006: 103-109.
11. Mehta SC and Somasundaran P. Mechanism of stabilization emulsions using hybrid siloxane Polymers. Langmuir. 24; 2008: 4558-4563.
12. Hill RM. Silicone Surfactants 3rdedition. Academic Press, San Diego CA. 2002.793.
13. Israel C and Frederick WGF. Semipermeable composite membranes produced from silicone based emulsions applied to porous substrates. EP 0242069 A2. 1987.
14. Grigoras S and Lane TH. Conformation analysis of substituted polysiloxanes polymers. In Silicon-Based Polymer Science: A Comprehensive Resource; Advances in Chemistry. 224; 1990: 125-144.
15. Arkles B, Ed. A survey of Properties and Chemistry: Silicon, Germanium, Tin and Lead Compounds, Metal Alkoxides, Diketonate and Carboxylates. Edited by Gelest Inc Catalog and William Leigh. Tullytown, PA 19007- 6308 USA; 386-428.
16. Gang SC, et al. Enhancement of the stability of BCNU using self-emulsifying drug delivery systems (SEDDS) and in vitro antitumor activity of self-emulsified BCNU-loaded PLGA wafer. International Journal of Pharmaceutics. 301; 2005: 6-14.
17. Mason TG, et al. Extreme emulsification: formation and structure of nanoemulsions. Condensed Matter Physics. 9; 2006; 193-199.
18. Becher P. Emulsions: Theory ad Practice. New York: Oxford University Press. 3rded. 2001.
19. Leal-Calderon F, et al. Emulsion Science: Basic Principles. New York: Springer. 2nd ed. 2007.
20. Petsev DN, ed. Emulsions: Structure stability and Interactions. New York: Elsevier. 2004.
21. Becher P ed. Encyclopedia of Emulsion Technology, Vol. 1: Basic Theory. New York: Marcel Drekker. 1983.
22. Becher P ed. Encyclopedia of Emulsion Technology, Vol. 2: Applications. New York: Marcel Dekker. 1985.
23. Becher P ed. Encyclopedia of Emulsion Technology, Vol. 3: Basic Theory, Measurement Applications. New York: Marcel Dekker. 1988.
24. Mason TG, et al. Nanoemulsions: formation structure and Physical Properties. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter. 18; 2006: R635-66.
25. Anton N and Vandamme TF. Nano-emulsions and micro-emulsions: Clarifications of the critical differences. Pharmaceutical Research. 28; 2011: 978-85.
26. Meleson K, et al. Formation of Concentrated nanoemulsions by extreme shear. Soft Matter. 2; 2004: 109-23.
27. McClements DJ. Nanoemulsions versus microemulsions terminology, differences and similarities. Soft Matter. 8; 2012: 1719.
29. McClements DJ. Edible Nanoemulsions: fabrication, Properties and functional performance. Soft Matter.7; 2011:2297-2316.
30. Gutierrez JM, et al. Nanoemulsions: new applications and optimization of their preparation. Current Opinion in Colloid Interface Science. 13; 2008: 245-51.
31. Korolova MY and Yurtov EV. Nanoemulsions: the properties methods of Preparations and Promising applications. Russian Chemical Reviews. 81; 2012: 21-43.
32. Michael MF and Thomas GM. Advanced nanoemulsions. Annual Review of Physical Chemistry. 63; 2012: 493-518.
33. Bibette J, et al. Surfactant stabilized emulsions. Current Opinion in Colloid and Interface Science. 69; 1992: 746-751.
34. Taylor, AJ. Foamable silicone compositions and the methods there of. US patent 6121210. 2000.
35. Fernando LC, et al. Emulsion Science: Basic Principles. Second Edition. 2007: 41.
36. Shinoda K and Saito H. The Stability of O/W type emulsions as functions of temperature and the HLB of emulsifiers: the emulsification by PIT method. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science. 30; 1969: 258-263.
37. Fryd MM and Mason T. Time-dependent nanoemulsion droplet reduction by evaporative ripening. Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters. 1; 2010: 3349-3353.
38. Lee SJ and McClements DJ. Fabrication of Protein - stabilized nanoemulsions using a combined Homogenization and amphiphilic solvent dissolution/ evaporation approach. Food Hydrocolloids. 24; 2010: 560-569.
39. Wooster TJ, et al. Impact of oil type on nanoemulsion formation and Ostwald ripening stability. Langmuir. 24; 2008: 12758-12765.
40. Leong TSH, et al. Minimising oil droplet size using ultrasonic emulsification. Ultrasonics Sonochemistry. 16; 2009: 721-727.
41. Abismail B, et al. Emulsification by ultrasound: drop size distribution and stability. Ultrasonics Sonochemistry. 6; 1999: 75-83.
42. Bondy C and Sollner K. Quantitative experiments on emulsification by ultrasonic waves. Transactions of the Faraday Society. 32; 1936: 556-66.
43. Ugelstad J, et al. Emulsions polymerization of styrene with sodium hexadecyl sulphate/ hexadecanol mixture as emulsifiers, initiation in monomer. Die Makromolekulare Chemie. 175; 1974: 507.
44. Tang PL, et al. Miniemulsion Polymerisation- a comparative study of preparative variables. Journal of Applied Polymer Science. 43; 1991: 1059.
45. Landfester K, et al. Polyaddition in miniemulsions: a new route to polymer dispersions. Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics. 1; 2000: 201.
46. Harry Z, et al. Nanoemulsion Composite Microgels for orthogonal Encapsulation and Release. Advanced Materials. 24; 2012: 3838-3844.
47. Dendukuri D and Doyle PS. The synthesis and assembly of polymeric microparticles using microfluidics. Advanced Materials. 21; 2009: 4071.
48. Garti N. Double emulsions: Scope, Limitations and new achievements. Colloids and Surfaces A. 123/124; 1997: 233-246.
49. Bancroft WD. The theory of emulsification, V. Journal of Physical Chemistry. 17: 1912: 501-519.
50. Tadros TF and Vincent B. Encyclopaedia of Emulsion Technology. Marcel Dekker New York.1983: 129-285.
51. Sela Y, et al. Polymeric surfactants based on polysiloxanes- graft-poly (oxyethylene) for stabilization of multiple emulsions. Colloids and surfaces A: Physicochem. Eng. Aspects. 83; 1994: 143-150.
52. Hill RM, Silicone surfactants: Surfactant science series, Marcel Dekker Inc. 1999.
53. Utada AS, et al. Monodisperse double emulsions generated from a microcapillary device. Science. 308; 2005: 37-41.
54. Okushima S, et al. Controlled production of monodisperse double emulsions by two-step droplet breakup in microfluidic devices. Langmuir. 20; 2004: 9905-9908.
55. Terwagne D, et al. From a Bouncing Compound Drop to a Double Emulsion. Langmuir. 26; 2010: 11680-11685.
56. Shin-Hyun Kim, et al. Double emulsion drops with ultra thin shells for capsule templates. Lab Chip. 11; 2011: 3161-3166.
57. Hanson JA, et al. Nanoscale double emulsions stabilized by single-component block copolypeptides. Nature. 455; 2008: 85-89.
58. Vilanova N, et al. Preparation of Novel silicone multicompartment particles by multiple emulsion templating and their use as encapsulating systems. Langmuir. 29; 2013: 15414-15422.
59. Myers, D. Surfaces, interfaces, Advanced Colloids Principles and Applications, 2nd ed.; John Wiley & Sons: New York. 1999.
60. Herzi S, et al. Influence of Diffusive transport on the structural evolution of W/O/W Emulsions. Langmuir. 28; 2012: 17597-17608.
61. Somasundaran P, et al. Silicone emulsions. Interfacial aspects and applications. Emulsions. Household and Personal care today. n3/2010.
62. Nazir H, et al. Silicone oil emulsions: Strategies to improve their stability in hair care products. International Journal of Cosmetic Science. 36; 2013: 1-10.
63. Tommy S, et al. Stability of Suspensions, Emulsions, and Foams studied by a novel automated analyser. Langmuir. 20; 2004: 9007-9013.
64. Pal R, et al. Flow behaviour of oil in water in emulsions. The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering. 64; 1986: 3-10.
65. Choi SJ and Schowalter WR. Rheological properties of non-dilute suspensions of deformable particles. Physics of Fluids. 18; 1975: 420-427.
66. Sharman P. Principles of emulsion formation In: Emulsion Science. Chapter 4, Academic Press, London. 1968.
67. Bram A, et al. A study of silicone oil in water emulsions. Chemical Engineering Communications. 156; 1997: 227-246.
68. Mehta SC, et al. Variation in emulsion stabilization behaviour of hybrid Silicone Polymers with in molecular structure: Phase diagram study. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science. 333; 2009: 635-640.
69. Fengyan L, et al. Factors influencing droplet size of silicone oil emulsion with high solid content. China Petroleum Processing and Petrochemical Technology. 13; 2011: 21-26.
70. Tadros T. Fundamental Principles of emulsion rheology and their applications. Colloids and Surfaces. A. 91; 1994: 39-45.
71. Pal R. Effect of droplet size on rheology of emulsions. AIchE Journal. 42; 1996: 3181-3190.
72. Saadevandi BA and Zakin JL. A study of silicone oil-in-water emulsions. Chemical Engineering Communications. 156; 1997: 227-246.
73. Ravi Theaj Prakash U and Thiagarajan P. Nanoemulsions for drug delivery through various routes. Research in Biotechnology. 2; 2011: 1-13.
74. Sela Y, et al. Newly designed polysiloxane- graft-poly (oxyethylene) copolymeric surfactants: preparation, surface activity and emulsification properties. Colloid and Polymeric Science. 272; 1994: 684-691.
75. Anseth JW, et al. Interfacial rheology of graft-type polymeric siloxane surfactants. Langmuir. 19; 2003: 6349-6356.
76. Zelisko PM, et al. Water-in-silicone oil emulsion stabilizing surfactants formed from native albumin and r, x-triethoxysilylpropyl polydimethylsiloxane. Biomacromolecules. 9; 2008: 2153-2161.
77. Binks BP and Dong J. Emulsions and equilibrium phase behaviour in silicone oil + water + nonionic surfactant mixtures. Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering aspects. 132; 1998: 289-301.
78. Kawaguchi M and Kubota K. Rheo-optical properties of silicone oil emulsions in the presence of polymer emulsifiers. Langmuir. 20; 2004: 1126-1129.
79. Kawaguchi M, et al. Polymer adsorption effects on structures structures and rheological properties of silica suspensions. Langmuir. 11; 1995: 563-567.
80. Kreilgaard M. Influence of microemulsion on cutaneous drug delivery. Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews. 54; 2002: 77- 98.
81. Rhee YS, et al. Transdermal delivery of ketoprofen using microemulsions. International Journal of Pharmaceutics. 228; 2001: 161-170.
82. Azeem A, et al. Emerging role of micro emulsions in cosmetics. Recent Patents on Drug Delivery and Formulation. 2; 2008: 275-289.
83. Ma GH, et al. Multi-scale structures in emulsions and microsphere complex systems. China Particuology. 3; 2005: 296-303.
84. Ma GH, et al. Preparation of uniform microspheres and microcapsules by modified emulsification process. Macromolecular Symposia. 288; 2010: 41-48.
85. Hollenberg J, et al. Cosmetic makeup compositions comprising water-in-oil emulsions containing pigment. US- patent. 5,143,722. 1992.
86. Paul Gee R. Silicone emulsion for personal care application. EP 0579455B1. 1996.
87. Canfield L, et al. Silicone-organic hybrid emulsions in personal care applications. WO 2010025311A1. 2010.
88. Stephen JC, et al. Ed. Science and Technology of Silicones and Silicone Modified Materials. ACS Symposium Series, Washington, DC.964; 2007.
89. Smedt AD, et al. Measurement of silicone deposited on hair by various analytical methods. Cosmetics & Toiletries. 112; 1997: 39.
90. Karsheva M, et al. The choice of thickeners- A way to improve silicone deposition on hair. Journal of Chemical Technology and Metallurgy. 42; 2007: 187-194.
91. Andrew MM and Euan S R. Conditioning shampoo comprising a surfactant, a non-volatile silicone oil and guar hydroxypropyltrimonium chloride as a cationic conditioning polymer. US 5,085,857. 1992.
92. Thomas DB, et al. Emulsions of aminofunctional silicones. EP 2596050A1. 2013.
93. Gum ML, Water-in-volatile silicone emulsifier concentrates. US Patent 4782095A.1988.
94. Berthiaume MD and Baum AD. Organofunctionalized silicone resins for personal care applications. Journal of Society of Cosmetic Chemists. 48; 1997: 1.
95. William FN, Controlling Intestinal Gas. (2005-01-09). Retrieved 2007-07-31.
96. Ravi Theaj Prakash U and Thiagarajan P. Transdermal drug delivery systems influencing factors, study methods and therapeutic applications. International Journal of Pharmaceutics. 2; 2012: 366-374.
97. Mason SS. After shave lotions. US- 5449512 A. 1995.
98. Tomohiro I, et al. Cosmetic and topical skin preparation comprising higher alcohol-modified silicone. WO 2011 136389- A2. 2011.
99. Christine ME and Anne Ja.2012. Cosmetic or dermatological emulsions. WO 2012 062755 A3. 2012.
100. Zhou W. Officinal emulsified silicone oil substrate and application thereof. CN 102580107-A. 2013.
101. Brian B. Barrier formulation comprising a silicone based emulsion. WO2005 002537 A2. 2005.
102. Hwan Bae D, et al. Effect of Lecithin on dermal safety of nanoemulsion prepared from hydrogenated Lecithin and Silicone oil. Bulletin of Korean Chemical Society. 30; 2009: 821-824.
103. Scherze I and Muschiolik G. Effects of various whey protein hydrolysates on the emulsifying and surface properties of hydrolysed lecithin. Colloids and surfaces B: Biointerfaces. 21; 2001: 107.
104. Hyder A, et al. Silicone emulsions for delivery of healthcare actives. WO 2013119633 A1. 2013.
105. Levelle L, et al. The disassembly, reassembly and stability of CCMV protein capsids. Journal of Virological Methods.146; 2007: 311-16.
106. Chang CB, et al. Curvature dependence of viral protein structures on encapsidated nanoemulsion droplets. ACS Nano. 2; 2008: 281-86.
107. Zelisko PM and Brook MA. Stabilization of α- Chymotrypsin and Lysozyme entrapped in water in silicone oil Emulsions. Langmuir. 18; 2002: 8982-8987.
108. Anderson AB and Robertson CR. Absorption spectra indicate conformational analysis of myoglobin absorbed on polydimethylsiloxane. Biophysical Journal. 68; 1995: 2091-2097
109. Sun L, et al. Protein denaturation induced by cyclic silicones. Biomaterials. 18; 1997: 1593-1597
110. Li JK, et al. Poly (vinyl alcohol) nano particles prepared by freezing-thawing process for protein/peptide drug delivery. Journal of Controlled Release. 56; 1998: 117-126.
111. Chen J and Dickinson E. Effect of monoglycerides and diglycerol esters on viscoelasticity of heat set whey protein emulsion gels. International Journal of Food science and Technology. 34; 1999: 493-501.
112. Paul MZ, et al. Water in Silicone oil emulsion stabilizing surfactants formed from native albumin and α,ω- Triethoxysilylpropyl- polydimethylsiloxane. Biomacromolecules. 9; 2008: 2153-2161.
113. D Brett L, et al. Protein Adsorption and Excipient Effects on Kinetic Stability of Silicone Oil Emulsions. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences. 99; 2010: 1721.
114. Deborah MC, et al. Encapsulation of BSA using a modified W/O/O emulsion solvent removal method. Journal of Microencapsulation. 23; 2006: 183-84.
115. Yoon Y, et al. Microencapsulation Methods for delivery of protein drugs. Biotechnology and Bioprocess Engineering. 6; 2001: 213-230.
116. Alliny FN, et al. Immobilized Horseradish Peroxidase as a Reusable Catalyst for Emulsion Polymerization. Langmuir. 23; 2007: 1981-1987.
117. Kenichi S, et al. Active Interfacial Modifier: Stabilization Mechanism of Water in Silicone Oil Emulsions by Peptide-Silicone Hybrid Polymers. Langmuir. 26; 2010: 5349-5354.
118. Bernard PB, et al. Inversion of Silica- Stabilized emulsions induced by particle concentration. Langmuir. 21; 2005: 3296-3302.
119. Vasiliki B, et al. Protein- silicone synergism at liquid/liquid interfaces. Langmuir. 16; 2000: 4589-4593.
120. “Linear Polydimethylsiloxanes”, ECETOC Joint assessment of commodity chemical no 26.1994.
121. Silicone Environmental, Health and Safety Council of North America, Guidance for aerosol applications of silicone-based materials. 2001. (2001).
122. André Colas. Silicones in Pharmaceutical Applications. By Dow corning health care Industries. URL: http://www.dowcorning.com/content/publishedlit/51-993a-01.pdf.
123. Lili F and Donald O . Polymeric Bio surfactants. EP 2037942 A2. 2009.
124. Alian M, et al. Stable water-in-oil emulsions containing an emulsifier on oleyl-and/ or isostearyl-glycoside. US patent 6488946 B1. 2002
125. Baghali G, et al. Cyclodextrin stabilized emulsions and cyclodextrinosomes. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics.15; 2013: 17903-17914.
Received on 08.04.2014 Modified on 10.05.2014
Accepted on 18.05.2014 © RJPT All right reserved
Research J. Pharm. and Tech. 7(5): May, 2014; Page 561-568